Skip to Content

Define Contribution vs. Defined Benefit

What's the difference and how might it impact the cost of my medicare?
May 21, 2025 by
Define Contribution vs. Defined Benefit
Elkin Financial, Mike Elkin

What Is a Defined Contribution Plan? A Simple Guide for Retirees

When it comes to retirement planning, understanding the tools at your disposal can make all the difference. One of the most common—but often misunderstood—tools is the defined contribution plan. Whether you're just starting to think about retirement or already enjoying it, knowing how these plans work will help you manage your money wisely and make smarter decisions about Medicare, taxes, and long-term income.

Let’s break it down.

What Is a Defined Contribution Plan?

A defined contribution plan is a retirement savings plan where you—and possibly your employer—contribute money into a personal investment account over time. The amount of money you’ll have available in retirement depends on:

  • How much is contributed
  • How your investments perform
  • How you withdraw those funds during retirement

Unlike traditional pensions (also called defined benefit plans), there’s no guaranteed monthly income. Instead, you own the account, and it grows based on contributions and investment returns.

Common Types of Defined Contribution Plans

Chances are, if you’ve worked in the last few decades, you’ve had one of these:

  • 401(k) – Offered by private employers
  • 403(b) – Offered by nonprofits, schools, and churches
  • 457(b) – Common for government employees
  • Thrift Savings Plan (TSP) – For federal employees and military members

In each case, you can contribute a portion of your paycheck before taxes (or after taxes with Roth options), and many employers offer matching contributions up to a certain limit.

How Do They Work?

Let’s walk through the basics:

  1. You contribute a set amount each pay period—often pre-tax.
  2. Your employer may match some portion of your contribution.
  3. The money goes into investment options like mutual funds, bonds, or company stock.
  4. Your account grows tax-deferred (or tax-free with Roth contributions).
  5. At retirement, you withdraw funds, typically paying taxes as you go.

Defined Contribution vs. Defined Benefit: What’s the Difference?

Here’s a simple comparison:

Feature Defined Contribution (DC) Defined Benefit (DB - Pension)
Who contributes? You (and sometimes employer) Employer mostly
Investment risk? You Employer
Retirement income amount? Depends on account value Fixed monthly payout
Portability? Yes (goes with you) Often tied to your employer
Popular examples 401(k), 403(b), TSP Company or government pension

In short: With a defined contribution plan, you control the account—but you also carry the risk.

Why It Matters in Retirement

Defined contribution plans can be a major source of income in retirement—but they come with decisions and responsibilities.

Here’s what you need to think about:

1. How to Withdraw Wisely

Once you retire, your account doesn’t just turn into paychecks. You’ll need to decide:

  • How much to withdraw each year
  • Which investments to keep or sell
  • When to start taking Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) (usually by age 73)

2. Impact on Medicare

Your retirement income from a defined contribution plan affects your Medicare premiums.

If your income is above a certain level, you may pay more for:

  • Part B (medical insurance)
  • Part D (prescription drug coverage)

This is known as IRMAA (Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount). Planning your withdrawals carefully can help reduce or avoid these surcharges.

3. Taxes

Most defined contribution withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income—unless you contributed to a Roth 401(k), which may be tax-free if you meet the rules.

Tax-efficient withdrawals can help stretch your money further—and keep your Medicare costs down.

Tips for Managing a Defined Contribution Plan in Retirement

  1. Work with a trusted advisor. An experienced agent like Mike Elkin can help you balance income needs, taxes, and Medicare planning.
  2. Understand your investment options. Keeping too much in high-risk investments late in life could jeopardize your income.
  3. Don’t forget about fees. Investment and advisor fees can chip away at your returns.
  4. Know your RMD age. Missing an RMD can trigger a 50% penalty on the amount you should have withdrawn.
  5. Plan for longevity. Make sure your withdrawal strategy supports you for 20–30 years, not just 10.

How Elkin Financial Can Help

At Elkin Financial, we’re not just here to talk about Medicare—we’re your partner in retirement planning. I've helped hundreds of individuals navigate the big-picture questions like:

  • “How much can I withdraw each year?”
  • “How does this affect my Medicare premiums?”
  • “Should I roll over my 401(k)?”
  • “How do I turn this into consistent retirement income?”

The truth is, retirement planning doesn’t end the day you leave your job. And most retirees don’t need a complicated financial plan—they need clear answers, a solid strategy, and a partner who’s in it for the long haul.

Ready to Get Clarity on Your Retirement Income?

Whether you're already retired or just starting to plan your exit, we’re here to help you make the most of what you’ve earned.  Schedule a free consultation

You worked hard to build your retirement. Now let’s make sure it works hard for you.

Define Contribution vs. Defined Benefit
Elkin Financial, Mike Elkin May 21, 2025
Share this post
Archive